Pumpkin Pie: Soy Free, Vegan and Gluten Free

I have several food memories from childhood. Most of them are fond such as using cookie cutters to cut out Christmas cookies and decorating them. Or the smell of homemade bread; warm cookies straight out of the oven after walking home from school.

Some of them are not so fond. The one that sticks out for me and was a defining moment has to do with Thanksgiving and pumpkin pie.

I always liked pumpkin pie, so when it came time to “order” my dessert at a turkey supper fundraiser I asked for pumpkin pie. (I was quite young, I’m thinking 7 or 8). Much to my dismay, it came to me gray. Yes, gray! I could not eat it and I have been forever grossed out by anything pumpkin that did not come from either my mom or myself.

To this day, I will only eat something pumpkin if I make it. I have never and will never eat anything pumpkin that I do not make myself. Like I said, it was a defining moment.

Pumpkin Pie

So, when dairy and eggs became a no-no, I had to adapt and started making pumpkin pie with tofu. Surprisingly, it tastes wonderful and almost like my old recipe from childhood.

However, many people are allergic to soy. Or they want to avoid soy because it is primarily genetically modified. Or maybe you are like me and try to avoid soy for other reasons.

So I adapted a recipe from More Choices by Cheryl D. Thomas-Peters to try a soy free, vegan pumpkin pie recipe to share here. I hesitate to share it because I like the tofu version pumpkin pie better and I only like to post recipes I would eat over and over again.

Yet, with Thanksgiving a week away I thought maybe this could help someone and since I went through the work to adapt the recipe, make it and take a picture I might as well post it. Given my past experience with pumpkin pie I’m quite picky. So as for me, my only complaint about this pie is that it is a little dense for me and I prefer something more light and fluffy. Everybody else who ate it noticed no difference from either a “regular” pumpkin pie or my tofu pumpkin pie.

For the pie crust I relied on a recipe from Cybele Pascal’s The Allergen-Free Baker’s Handbook.

What is your fondest or worst food memory? Do you like pumpkin pie?

Pumpkin Pie: Soy Free, Vegan and Gluten Free


  • One 15 oz. can pumpkin puree
  • 2 T. tapioca starch
  • 6 T. water
  • 3/4 cup coconut sugar
  • 1/2 tsp. salt
  • 1 tsp. cinnamon
  • 1/2 tsp. ginger
  • 1/2 tsp. allspice
  • 1/4 cup powdered rice milk
  • 1 1/4 cups water
  • 1/2 cup sorghum flour
  • Gluten Free or regular pie crust (I use a recipe from Cybele Pascal’s The Allergen Free Baker’s Handbook)


  1. Prepare your pie crust for filling.
  2. Preheat oven to 425 degrees.
  3. In a large bowl place pumpkin puree.
  4. In another bowl, combine starch and 6 T. water.  Stir until starch is dissolved.
  5. Pour into bowl with the pumpkin.
  6. Add coconut sugar, salt, and spices. Stir to combine well.
  7. In a liquid measuring cup place 1 1/4 cup water.  Add the powdered rice milk and stir to combine.
  8. Add to pumpkin mixture.
  9. Add sorghum flour to mixture and stir until well combined.
  10. Pour into pie crust.
  11. Cover the crust with little strips of aluminum foil.
  12. Put in oven and bake for 15 minutes.
  13. After 15 minutes, turn oven to 350 degrees. and bake for 65 minutes more.
  14. Cool before cutting.

Tater Tot Casserole—Free of Gluten, Milk, Egg, Corn, Soy

Tater Tot Casserole

What do you want most for dinner on a cold night after a long day? I don’t know about you, but I want comfort food. And I want it to be easy. And delicious. So every now and then, I pull out an old index card with a handwritten recipe on it. Something from days gone by. That something…..the old tater tot casserole. Who doesn’t love tater tots!?!?!?!? Thankfully, you can find allergy free tater tots. I have found brand name and store brand tater tots to either have milk, gluten or corn in them. But, surprisingly, not at Aldi! … Continue reading


Flavor Your Rice Seven Different Ways

Flavor Your Rice

Rice doesn’t have to be boring!  Spice it up! Want Salsa Rice?  How about Spicy BBQ Rice?  Teriyaki and Italian anyone?  You can even make it sweet with Apple Cinnamon Raisin! Find the recipes to make these flavors of rice (and more) by reading this article I wrote for My Life With Food Allergies. Also shared at Allergy Free Wednesday.

Leave a comment

How To Roast Pumpkin Seeds – A Photo Tutorial


We carved a pumpkin yesterday.  It was a project that drew neighbor kids.  Everyone enjoyed it. We saved the seeds. Time to roast them.  First, you need to get all that stringy goop off of the seeds. Place them in a bowl of coldish water and let set for awhile. After 5 minutes or so, use your hands to scoop up seeds and use your hand as a strainer.  Do this over and over.  Then let set for a few more minutes. After resting a bit, scoop up seeds and let the water and stringy stuff fall off into the … Continue reading

Leave a comment

Allergy Free Cookbooks-A Brief Review of My Cookbook Collection

Allergy Free Cookbooks

Recently I received a free copy of the cookbook Finally, Food I Can Eat by Shirley Plant. This is more than a cookbook. It could be called a guide book. The first 45 pages are chuck full of all sorts of information ranging from food substitutes, food additives, replacements, common allergens, food combining, and food families etc. The rest of the book contains recipes in every category which are free from dairy, wheat, yeast, soy, eggs, corn, sugar, nuts and nightshades. It is important to state that while this book does contain a lot of naturally gluten free recipes, it … Continue reading

1 Comment

Fall Fruit Sauce

Fall Fruit Sauce

I made Savory Squash Soup yesterday and it was delish. If you have not tried it yet, by all means….go, print out the recipe. You will love the soup even if you are not a big squash person. And as always, when I cooked the squash for the soup I had leftovers. I actually plan it that way. I buy a bigger squash so that I will have leftover squash. I was going to make Not Your Mama’s Chocolate Shake, but I didn’t have ripe bananas. Don’t you hate it when you want to make something, only to find out … Continue reading


Living Without’s Gluten Free Holidays GIVEAWAY!!!!!


Living Without’s Gluten Free and More magazine has come out with a special Holidays edition. And you can get one for FREE! I have been granted permission to give away THREE copies of the holiday guide. I have already received my copy and read it front to back on the same day it came. I know I’ll be perusing it over and over the next few months. This Holidays guide is chuck full of 75 recipes and many are more than gluten free. Many come with egg free options and are milk free too! Maybe you are not gluten free…..you’d … Continue reading


Make Your Own Can Of Condensed Tomato Soup

Beef Stew1

Fall is knocking on our door and I’m ready to start making soups and stews again. In fact I made this stew last night and it was good. If you haven’t tried it yet, you should. One of my favorite soup recipes from childhood is a chili recipe that requires a can of condensed tomato soup. I started making my own condensed version about 4 years ago. I took these pictures back in 2012 and am just now getting around to sharing it. You’ll need oil, starch, spices, milk (dairy free or not), and tomato paste. Heat oil on stove … Continue reading


Food at Marshall’s Department Store? You Bet!

Marshalls food1

I have some fun news for you! You can find allergy free, gluten free and health foods at Marshall’s and TJ Maxx Department Stores. You can read all about the different finds and categories of food on this post I wrote for My Life With Food Allergies. Also shared at Allergy Free Wednesday. Gluten Free Wednesday.

Leave a comment

Pumpkin Chai Spice Breakfast Bars

Pumpkin Chai Breakfast Bars

I saw the stats. The Grab and Go Breakfast Bars were a HUGE hit! I had mentioned I was working on a new flavor. Today, it’s yours…. Pumpkin Chai Breakfast Bars. Great autumn breakfast, although I would eat these any time of year. But now would be the time to stock up on canned pumpkin as it is always cheaper in the fall. These are not overly pumpkin for those of you who prefer a mild taste. The chai spices are not heavy either. You may want to check out the Grab and Go Breakfast Bars post for all the … Continue reading

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... 1 Comment